TV ethernet

From: william (WILLIAMA)18 Jan 2017 17:37
To: william (WILLIAMA) 15 of 49
Just a quick follow up. I've now tried a whole bunch of different speed tests and I'm beginning to suspect that the OOKLA app is the dodgy one. 

Using my laptop, all agree that the speed squirting out of the patch cable is between 145 and 165 mbps. Using the telly, OOKLA says between 18 and 25, Netflix's own diagnostics is consistent at 33.5, and all the other web based tests (I tried 5 different ones) returned between 65 and 108. 

Netflix is looking at its own streaming servers and that's probably what its app is using. As all the other web based apps returned a far higher result than OOKLA I think that it (which is a beta in any case) is probably not playing nicely with WebOS and the television.

Bored now...
EDITED: 18 Jan 2017 19:22 by WILLIAMA
From: ANT_THOMAS18 Jan 2017 17:43
To: william (WILLIAMA) 16 of 49
Well if you're getting 108 then it should handle high bitrate stuff fine enough. All depends on the server pushing at the other end!
From: koswix18 Jan 2017 18:16
To: william (WILLIAMA) 17 of 49
Ookla annoys me. Don't know about other ISPs, but on virgin it always defaults to a speed test server hosted by VM at your local VM connection point thingy. That's great for telling me the quality of my line, but doesn't give much insight to real speed.

If VM are hosting the server then a) no traffic is going on to the Internet, so it's not an Internet connection speed test anymore, and b) if VM are hosting the server, then they can traffic shape the transfer and ensure I get a top speed even when their network is congested and running like a pigs arse.
From: william (WILLIAMA)19 Jan 2017 01:13
To: koswix 18 of 49
It did exactly the same when I tried it on WebOS (this was the beta non-flash version). In this case, the other servers gave similar results.

The VirginMedia way of working is strange and made worse by the hugely old-fashioned technology that makes up the majority of their consumer base. It's no wonder they fiddle their bandwidth figures, like Volkswagon whose cars run on fairy tears and emit honey and angel farts.

They have a unique client server model, that nobody who ever ran a client server setup was ever stupid enough to imagine - except them. 10% of their cable network is reserved for things like iPlayer, catch up. Netflix etc. Nothing wrong with that. The problem is they also stick ordinary interactions with the set-top boxes there. Press a menu button and your Tivo nips off onto the cable network alongside Netflix and Angry Birds to check what to do and get the next screen. Just about possible so far - except - they divide up that 10% in equal geographic chunks. The bad news is that if you have 50 people in your chunk playing Angry Birds and watching Netflix, it may take you 30 seconds just to get to the channel you've selected from the menu, that took you another 30 seconds to get to. And of course, they divide up broadband the exact same way. 

 
From: koswix19 Jan 2017 10:00
To: william (WILLIAMA) 19 of 49
Ah, so that's why the tivo box is do slow? Sounds a bit daft.

When I switched back to virgin (about 18 months ago) there was huge network congestion issues, pretty much unusable at peak times. They did some upgrades and I've got to say it's been pretty flawless since. Can max out my 200mb line downloading steam games, xbox games etc. Wanted to play borderlands the other week, xbox said it needed a 4 gig update. By the time I'd made coffee and a sandwich it was ready to go.
From: ANT_THOMAS19 Jan 2017 10:09
To: koswix 20 of 49
I can't really complain about speeds either. No idea how busy the network is locally but when I moved in there wasn't any BT fibre, only about 4mbps ADSL so Virgin was the only reasonable option. If only the upload was better.
From: koswix19 Jan 2017 11:44
To: ANT_THOMAS 21 of 49
Getting the option of 1gbps synchronous soon :D
From: ANT_THOMAS19 Jan 2017 11:52
To: koswix 22 of 49
Cost? No chance of that near me. And I only bought the house because Virgin available. Some people thought I was stupid for not viewing houses with shit Internet, I refused to have any bathroom type issues!
From: graphitone19 Jan 2017 12:19
To: koswix ANT_THOMAS 23 of 49
Aye, I've been similarly benefitted by Virgin, internet access has always been reliable and fast. We downgraded to 50mb (from 100mb) a few months ago, the only thing I ever max out our connection with is Steam downloads and they're few and far between nowadays, but when I do I get the full download speed. We don't stream anything (yet), so the service is fine for what we use it for.

I've been looking into the Virgin V6 boxes which purports to do what Sky have been crowing about recently, recording on that device and stream to another (which will let me watch recorded shows on my PC). It does come with some caveats though:
 
Quote: 

Virgin TV V6 box: Only available for customers with Mix TV package and above and Virgin Media broadband minimum VIVID 100 (up to 100 Mbps). Content available to view depends on your TV package. Virgin TV V6 box remains property of Virgin Media.

1Netflix subscription required at extra cost..

2To watch 4K Ultra HD shows, you’ll need a 4K Ultra HD compatible TV.

3Box Sets are only available with selected TV packs.

Virgin TV Anywhere & App: Content available to view depends on TV package. Not all channels/content from relevant pack available. Selected programmes may not be available to view. Live streaming and On Demand available in the UK with broadband or WiFi internet access only. Access via PC, Mac or TV Anywhere App (selected iOS devices and Android™ mobiles and tablets only). Virgin TV customers with a Virgin TV V6 box can stream or download selected recorded programmes on the Virgin TV Anywhere App on selected devices (this feature is not accessible via PC or Mac) see virginmedia.com/help/tvanywhere for further details.  Minimum 800Kbps recommended per device accessing the service concurrently. Maximum of 2 devices per account can watch TV.  On Demand only available to M+ or Mix TV packages and above. Visit virginmedia.com for full terms and conditions..

From: koswix19 Jan 2017 12:43
To: graphitone 24 of 49
My contract is up with virgin this month, considering ditching the telly entirely - but suspect that will cost more because of stupid pricing.

Also need to ring them about my other account (at mum's house, was easier to leave it in my name then change it!), currently paying 35 a month for 20mb broadband only. Their minimum package now is 34 quid for 50mb :@
From: koswix19 Jan 2017 13:14
To: ANT_THOMAS 25 of 49
Not sure yet, not cheap I'd guess.

It's these guys laying fibre, might be coming near you?

https://www.cityfibre.com/network/
From: william (WILLIAMA)19 Jan 2017 16:08
To: graphitone 26 of 49
I'm supposed to be getting a V6 box this afternoon - not convinced the engineer will turn up though as the ordering and delivery system is a bit fucked up at present. I ordered online last week and got an appointment for Monday with an email about the prices etc. Engineer never arrived and when I phoned to ask why, I was told there was no record of my ever placing an order. 

That's why I was looking at network speeds for the telly. They were prattling on about having the cable modem next to the V6 box, but since all my cables are tucked away under floors with hardwood on top, and my modem is in a different room with a couple of servers, it's not exactly easy to move around. Apparently all they need is a decent network link and I was able to thread an additional ethernet cable though and stick a gigabit switch on it - and so on and so on...
From: CHYRON (DSMITHHFX)19 Jan 2017 16:29
To: koswix 27 of 49
quote: koswix
a 4 gig update.

wtf?

From: koswix19 Jan 2017 18:32
To: CHYRON (DSMITHHFX) 28 of 49
Yup. I hate modern console games for that.

Got a new controller at Xmas, connected it up and the xbox immediate says "your controller needs an update...". Wtf! It's a Fucking controller! What are they doing with the update, adding more buttons?
From: CHYRON (DSMITHHFX)19 Jan 2017 20:57
To: koswix 29 of 49
Can they not do deltas?
From: koswix20 Jan 2017 01:13
To: CHYRON (DSMITHHFX) 30 of 49
Was the first time launching the game, so likely that it was actually downloading most of the game - not sure of the reasoning but when you install a game it normally doesn't install the game data until you launch the game itself. Like its Fucking surprised that you paid for a game and then wanted to play it.

Disvlaimer: I bought/installed the game for my birthday, last January. Got round to playing it in December
From: CHYRON (DSMITHHFX)20 Jan 2017 01:39
To: koswix 31 of 49
Ah, yeah that's plausible.
From: william (WILLIAMA)20 Jan 2017 09:36
To: koswix 32 of 49
Curiously, the calendar app on my phone has a note of your birthday, but not my g/f of 35 years.
From: koswix20 Jan 2017 09:46
To: william (WILLIAMA) 33 of 49
Do you need my address to post the present?

From: koswix20 Jan 2017 09:47
To: william (WILLIAMA) 34 of 49
Actually, what date does it have? Can probably work out which service it was scraped from by the fake date.